Cookit Homepage Cookit is published by e2bn

Butterfly Cakes (1970's Party)

This recipe is in categories Baking, Party food, Postwar Modern
  • Get the Flash Player to see this player.

  • Butterfly Cakes
    Butterfly Cakes
About this recipe
Healthiness : (97 votes)
Difficulty:  2 out of 5 difficulty

Always use oven gloves when handling hot cake tins.

An adult may need to help when cutting off the tops, as a sharp knife is needed.

Preparation Time: 10 mins to make the mixture, 15 minutes to assemble cakes
Cooking Time: 20-25 minutes
Number of servings: Makes 12-15 cakes
Serving suggestions: Serve as part of a party buffet or just as a tea time treat
View a modern version of this recipe

Butterfly cakes were extremely popular at children's parties - they look attractive and the buttercream icing makes them sweet to eat.  They are also quite easy to make.

By the 1970's, many kitchens had acquired food processors which helped a lot with mixing.  Before then, you had to be very careful to mix everything in the correct order
and a lot of beating was required to make the mixture light - very time consuming.  In this podcast, everything goes into the food mixer and it is quickly ready to put into the cake cases - a lot less work.

You will notice that they are decorated with shop bought coloured sugar strands - another convenience for the modern cupboard.

It is thought that butterfly cakes came about from fairy cakes that had risen too much - so the tops were cut off so they could be iced more easily - and soon someone thought of turning them into 'wings'.

Nowadays, it is useful to add a little baking powder to the self raising flour, if you want to make butterfly cakes, to ensure that they do rise enough.

For images of the cooking process see our Butterfly Cakes Images

With thanks to Caroline Cuerden, The Hair Company for their help with this podcast.

The cakes:
  • 100g (4 oz) soft butter
  • 100g (4oz) caster sugar
  • 100g (4oz) self-raising flour
  • pinch of baking powder
  • 2 eggs - at room temperature

The butter cream frosting:
  • 50g (2oz) soft butter
  • 100g (4oz) icing sugar
  • 15ml (1 tbsp) milk
  • colouring (optional)
  • sugar strands to decorate (optional)
  • Patty tin
  • Food mixer
  • Wire rack
  • Bowl
  • Fork
  • Knife
Making and cooking it
Always wash your hands before preparing food Always wash your hands before preparing food.

  • Grease well 12 - 15 bun (patty) tins or prepare the same number of small cake cases
  • Turn on the oven to 185C / 375F / Gas no 5
  • Cream the butter and caster sugar together in the food processor until light and fluffy
  • Add the eggs and flour a little at a time, mixing in the food processor
  • Drop a large teaspoon of mixture into each of the bun tins (or cake cases)
  • Bake for 20 - 25 mins (until golden and well risen)
  • Take from the oven and cool on wire rack
  • Whilst they are cooling, make the frosting by gradually beating the sifted icing sugar into the soft butter, adding a little milk as it becomes too difficult
  • Split the frosting up to add a few drops of colouring if wanted
  • When the cakes are completely cool, carefully slice off the risen top
  • Cut each top in half to make the wings
  • Put a portion of the butter frosting on each cake (you can pipe it if wished)
  • Place the 2 wings on each cake, pressing the thicker ends into the frosting
  • Sprinkle with a little sieved icing sugar or sugar strands
Butterfly Cakes (1970's Party) - print view  Butterfly Cakes (1970's Party) - print view

If you tried this recipe and liked it, tell us about it
More podcasts
If you enjoyed this podcast, there are plenty more to choose from!

Modern podcasts:
History podcasts:

Or Subscribe to the podcasts RSS feed

Required fields are bold

If you include your name it will be published next to your comment. You can use a nickname or screen name to remain anonymous. We will keep this information only whilst your comment remains on the website.

We use a third party, AP Johnson trading as Lee-Capelle, to manage, edit and verify your comment. In dealing with comments they may be able to see your account details but they are only allowed to use the information to deal with the content.

If you require more information about how we use your data or require us to remove a contribution you have made please contact: The DPO, E2BN, Unit 1, Saltmore Farm, New Inn Road, Hinxworth, SG7 5EZ

Fortune Cookies
Write your fortunes/messages on strips of white paper about 10cm by 1.5cmPreheat the oven to...